Discovering Bach’s Secret Tempo Code
ABOUT: “Discovering Bach’s Secret Tempo Code” is an ongoing free e-book which is periodically expanded, updated, and revised, representing a total of over 30 years’ reflection and research. I first discovered what I referred to as Bach’s “secret system of tempo” in 1992 as a graduate student in piano and musicology at the University of Kansas. The project was well underway from 1992-2002, which was put on hiatus in 2002 for the next 20 years. In 2022, I resumed working on the project aiming to make it into a book. However, instead of constantly struggling to get a “final product” to “cast into stone” for this highly technical project (i.e., a traditional print book), I thought it would be easier and more practical to simply present this book-in-progress as a blog on this website. I call this a “Book-in-a-Blog”! This way, I may add and edit content periodically as time permits for your reading pleasure. Please enjoy this free Book-in-a-Blog!
Preludes & Fugues and Other Works for Organ (BWV 531-590)
The prelude and fugue are both in 4/4, and have a measure ratio, 40:74, and tempo ratio, 63:72, resulting in a close 2:3 duration ratio, 2:32-4:06. One and a half more measures for the prelude, 42, and two fewer measures for the fugue, 72, result in a 2:3 duration ratio, 2:40-4:00…
Orgelbüchlein (BWV 599-644)
The Orgelbüchlein consists of 46 organ chorales organized sequentially by seasons according to the church calendar. The following bullet list summarizes Bach’s large-scale organization:
Schübler Chorales (BWV 645-50)
The Schübler Chorales belong to a small handful of works printed and published during Bach’s lifetime. In 1747, late in the composer’s life, Bach assembled a new set of six chorales in which five of the six (Nos. 1, 3, 4, 5, 6) were transcribed to organ from movements selected from five previously composed cantatas, published in 1748 by Johann Georg Schübler (ca. 1720-1755).
The “Great 18” Chorales (BWV 651-668)
O Lamm Gottes, unschuldig is the only movement in the Great 18 that does not have a duration partner. In rare cases like this, Bach’s usual procedure was to create a whole number duration. In this beautiful “Lamb of God” movement, Bach apparently chose a duration of nine minutes, 9:00, and achieved this with pinpoint accuracy.
Clavierübung III (BWV 552, 669-689, 802-805)
The third part to the Clavierübung (commonly referred to as the “German Organ Mass”) consists of a grand prelude and fugue (commonly referred to as “St. Anne”), the longest of all Bach’s preludes and fugues, at the beginning and end of the opus. Between these bookends lies 21 chorale preludes and 4 duets. The following bullet list summarizes Bach’s large-scale organization:
Inventions & Sinfonias (BWV 772-801)
The 15 Inventions first appeared as “Preambles” in a different order in the Notebook for Wilhelm Friedemann Bach. Analysis reveals a deliberate plan of order and symmetry in the Inventions applying the same tempos to both sets, suggesting that Bach organized the Inventions and Preambles simultaneously. Such an impressive mathematical feat could be understood as the “preamble-invention conundrum,
The Well-Tempered Clavier, Book 1 (BWV 846-869)
The prelude and fugue have a close 4:3 beat ratio, 140:108, and virtually precise 4:3 tempo ratio, 63:48, resulting in a 1:1 duration ratio. In other words, the beat ratio equals the tempo ratio resulting in a 1:1 duration ratio (4:3 beat ratio ÷ 4:3 tempo ratio = 1:1 duration ratio).
The Well-Tempered Clavier, Book 2 (BWV 870-893)
The prelude and fugue have a close 6:7 beat ratio, 136:166, and 4:7 tempo ratio, 48:84, resulting in a close 3:2 duration ratio, 2:50-1:58. Two more measures for the prelude, 36, and one more measure for the fugue, 84, result in a 6:7 beat ratio, 144:168, and a 3:2 duration ratio, 3:00-2:00.
Sonatas for Viola da Gamba and Harpsichord (BWV 1027-29)
The first and second movements have a close 1:1 beat ratio, 336:339, and 1:1 tempo ratio, 84:84, resulting in virtually equal durations, 4:00 and 4:02.
Brandenburg Concertos (BWV 1046-51)
The first and third movements have a close 7:4 beat ratio, 476:278, and 7:8 tempo ratio, 84:96, resulting in a close 2:1 duration ratio, 5:37-2:53. The second movement has a duration a little over four minutes, 4:03.